Subscribe to RSS - State of the craft

What happens to writers if B&N dies?

Barnes & Noble storefront

The continuing decline of Barnes & Noble prompts Alex Shephard to discuss what's at risk if the big chain shrinks further or closes and publishers lose one of their biggest revenue streams: "The most literary of novels will be shunted to smaller publishers. Some will probably never be published at all. And rigorous nonfiction books, which often require extensive research and travel, will have a tough time finding a publisher with the capital to fund such efforts."

Journalism and the war on science

Clay figures of journalists

Andrew Seifter reviews a Shawn Otto book, The War on Science, quoting Otto on how journalism distorts governance: "'Journalists look for conflict to find an angle,' he writes, 'so there are always two sides to every story.' A scientist, by contrast, would say that 'one of these claims can be shown to be objectively false and it’s poor reporting to paint this as a controversy.' As a result, the journalistic approach 'tends to skew public policy in counterfactual directions.'"

Journalism's continuing lack of diversity

Old newsroom

Columbia Journalism Review editors report on their review of a century of Pulitzer Prize winners and conclude that the honorees always have been — and still are — mostly white: "Progress has been so slow that the percentage of non-white winners over the last decade is essentially identical to the percentage over the last 100 years." Also, Howard W. French on how the history of black people in journalism mirrors the history of race in America.

A plan for remaking the news business

University building

Economist Julia Cagé proposes a solution to the news media's financial crisis — a new form of organization modeled after major universities that combine commercial and nonprofit activities: "The question is not whether the media should be subsidized. It is rather whether they should be granted a favorable legal and tax status in recognition of their contribution to democracy — a status comparable to that long enjoyed by many other participants in the knowledge economy."

Do science writers need to be scientists?

Scientist at microscope

Sabrina Talukdar writes about a debate in front of British doctoral students that began with a majority supporting the proposition that journalists covering science should have a background in science. By the end, that sentiment had shifted strongly in the opposite direction: "The final result saw a swing to 73% voting against the motion and only 27% remaining in support." Also, Paul Raeburn on what every journalist should know about science.

Can artificial intelligence do journalism?

Computer keyboard

Sarah O'Connor tested her writing skill against a machine named Emma to see who could do a better job on a business story. The answer? It's not clear: "In truth, most people who work on artificial intelligence admit it is not going to make humans obsolete any time soon. It is simply not intelligent enough yet. What is beginning to happen, though, is more subtle but no less important. The lines are beginning to blur between work done by humans and that done by machines."

Why Oliver laughs at science coverage

John Oliver

Jon Brooks talks to one of the consultants on that John Oliver segment on science reporting, Health News Review publisher Gary Schwitzer, and asks about the journalism that gave rise to the jokes: "We treat anything published in a journal as if it’s from Moses coming down the mountaintop with a set of stone tablets. Journals were never meant to be sources for the 24-hour news cycle — they are meant to be a forum for discussion among scientists."

A data journalism project gets misused

Oxycontin sign in drug store

ProPublica won praise in 2013 when it posted a database on doctors' prescribing habits, pinpointing likely cases of abuse. But now, Stephen Engelberg writes, the independent journalism organization has discovered that some people are using the database for purposes that aren't praiseworthy: "We picked up clear signs that some readers are using the data for another purpose: To search for doctors likely to prescribe them some widely abused drugs, many of them opioids."

What skills do hiring editors want?

Sign on door reading

Benjamin Mullin talks to Mark Stencel, an author of a new Tow-Knight Center report that asked 39 news leaders what they are looking for when hiring: "Having more than one specialized skill can make a potential recruit more marketable. But being excellent at a combination of two things, or even a few things that logically go together, seems more realistic than trying to be excellent at everything." More from Steve Buttry.

As reporting jobs fade, PR jobs boom

Keyboard with

Mike Rosenberg noticed something that disturbed him during his most recent journalism job hunt: "For every one job result for a reporter, photojournalist or TV producer, you’ll get 10 results for jobs available to people with journalism backgrounds or degrees to switch careers toward marketing, advertising and — most of all — public relations." He researched further and learned that there are now 4.8 PR people per journalist, more than twice the ratio of 15 years ago.